Eight years working on renovations and alterations early in my career taught me a lot about tracking down leaks.
The short version
You don't need to know everything in this guide to get a leak fixed. You need to know two things: it won't fix itself, and what to tell whoever comes to look at it.
Leave a leak through a winter, a few rainy weekends or a wet summer, and the insulation can turn black, with mould growing on the framing. Tracing it back to where the water gets in lets you work out what needs repairing or replacing.
Finding where the water gets in is the builder's job. Getting someone booked in before it gets worse is yours.
Something you can do to help speed up the process of getting it sorted is to take some notes and photos of what you're seeing. A few clues help your builder know where to start looking. Note down:
- Where it shows: which room, and whether it's on the ceiling or a wall.
- When it leaks: every time it rains, or only in heavy rain, or only when the wind's from one direction.
- Roughly how old the roof is, and whether the house was built before 2000 (that matters if the cladding needs work).
- A few photos: the marks on the ceiling or walls, and anything you can see of the roof from ground level. Don't climb a ladder or get into the roof space to take them. That's where my inspection comes in.
That's enough for a builder to start on. If that's as far as you want to go, book a callback and send your notes and photos with the booking. I'll look at them before we talk.
From here it gets into the detail: how I track a leak down, what I look for on a roof, and how to decide what it needs. None of this is something you need to do yourself. Getting into roof spaces or onto roofs can be dangerous if you don't know what you're doing. I'm explaining the process so you can understand what goes into finding a leak properly, and tell a thorough investigation from a guess.
First, is it the roof?
A watermark on a ceiling is most likely the roof, but I'll check the plumbing first. I'll get into the roof space and have a look. If a pipe's wet, I'll check whether the pipe itself is leaking or whether water's tracking onto it from somewhere else. If it's the plumbing, that's a job for a plumber.
Then I'll look at the roof itself. You can tell a lot about its condition from a visual inspection. If it's a brand-new roof, I'd suspect the plumbing before the roof, although new roofs can leak too. If the roofing hasn't been installed very well, that's where I'd look harder first.
Follow the water uphill
Water runs downhill, so you follow it back up. I start in the roof space above the drip. It's easier if it's still wet up there: anything wet gives you part of the trail.
The insulation is one of the first things I look at. If water's been getting through it for a while, it can turn black or start growing mould. That gives you a clue about where water's been coming through. If I can't see where the water has come through the insulation directly above the watermark, I'll lift that batt and check the top of the ceiling underneath. Water could have travelled along the ceiling from somewhere else, so I'll follow any dampness or staining back to where it came through.
Then I look at the framing. Water leaves a track on timber where it's been running. The wood changes colour as if it's wet, but it's dry. Black building paper changes colour where water's been coming through it too. I follow that track uphill.
Where it comes out of the paper, I'll start looking at the section of roof above it. If it's running along a purlin, it could have travelled several metres before dripping off. Wind-driven rain can complicate things too. That's why you follow the water trail rather than assuming the leak is directly above the wet patch.
Often, sections of roof have to come off before you can say for sure where the water's getting in.
Ask when it leaks
I ask when it leaks. If it only leaks when the wind's from the north, look at how the iron's been lapped: how the sheets overlap.
On the roof: what I look for
Up on the roof, above the leak or along the purlin it's tracking down, I check every nail and screw.
- Loose nails. A loose nail leaks.
- Fixings in the wrong place. Through the ridge capping, the screw or nail should go through a crest of the corrugated iron, not the valley where the water runs.
- Ridge caps on a hip roof. Where the roof's cut on an angle and capped, it's harder to get the fixings dead on the crest, and water tracks up there. It's a classic spot.
- The joins between ridge caps, where two lengths meet and weren't done quite right.
- Rusty holes in the iron.
If the clues are pointing to a problem on the roof, that's where I take the inspection further. It's not something I'd ask you to get up there and check yourself. Book a callback, tell me where the water's showing inside, and I'll know where to start looking.
Repair or replace: the roof
Whether to repair or replace a roof comes down to its condition, your budget and how long you need it to last.
An older long-run iron roof with lead-head nails doesn't automatically need replacing. If the iron hasn't rusted through, the purlins are sound and the roof's generally been installed properly, there can still be plenty of life left in it.
Pulling the loose lead-head nails and replacing them with roofing screws is a common repair. Where the old nail holes are damaged, they can be cleaned up and sealed with a suitable roofing silicone before the screws go in. The silicone fills the damaged area that the rubber washer might not seal on its own. Any fixings in the wrong places can be addressed at the same time.
Sometimes that's a couple of days' work and relatively little in materials, compared with the cost of replacing the whole roof. Builders have been doing these repairs for years. It doesn't give you a new roof, but if the underlying roof is sound, it can extend its life considerably.
I wouldn't normally recommend repainting a roof just because we've repaired it. But if the galvanising is starting to deteriorate and surface rust is appearing, repainting may be worthwhile. That's something I'd get a painter involved with. If the roof's going to be painted, we'd also use a sealant that's compatible with the paint system.
A repair stops being worthwhile once the iron itself is rusting through. Holes under the ridge caps are a classic example. Screws and silicone won't save iron that's deteriorated that far. Patch it anyway and you've paid for a repair but still need a new roof. If your roof's at that point, whoever looks at it should tell you before you pay for a patch, not after.
With several leaks, we need to talk through how much longer a repair could reasonably keep the roof going and what it would cost, then compare that with replacing it. If you do replace it, prepainted steel roofing can come with a manufacturer's warranty against rusting through that runs to decades, though it's shorter the closer you are to the sea, and it depends on the roof being maintained as required.
And don't leave the roof till last. You don't see much benefit from spending money on a roof, but it's one of the most important parts of keeping a house going. People renovate and won't touch the roof, when it should come first if it's leaking or past its useful life.
Repair or reclad: the walls
Cladding's harder. A wall leak shows inside: wallpaper bubbling, brown marks on a wall. Rule out the roof and the plumbing first. If it's neither, I'll start looking at the wall cladding, flashings and penetrations.
One leak in a wall, particularly if it's been caught early, can often be fixed with a targeted repair. But I'll check over the cladding on the rest of the house as well. If there's a problem with one window head flashing, I'll look at the others to see if they've been done the same way. The same goes for weatherboard corners and soakers.
Sometimes it's just one poorly flashed pipe penetration causing the leak, and the rest of the cladding is fine. Other times, you find the same problem in several places. And you don't really know what damage there is behind the cladding until you start removing some of it.
A targeted repair might mean replacing a few weatherboards, putting right the flashing over a window (the head flashing), or fixing a poorly detailed penetration. Some older houses have head flashings that were never detailed well, and some have none at all. On timber weatherboards, the corners often fail where the boards were mitred (cut at an angle to meet) without a soaker, the small flashing behind the joint. A corner box over the whole corner takes that risk away.
With plaster-finished claddings that have no visible joints (monolithic, in the trade), it's harder to tell how much damage is going on behind them.
Older fibre-cement weatherboards can get brittle and crack, letting water in. If the boards are otherwise sound, sealing the joints and small cracks can be a temporary repair. Checked over each year, with new cracks sealed as they appear, this can sometimes keep the cladding going for years longer. But it won't fix damage that's already developed behind the boards. Before anyone touches it: if your house was built before 2000, have the cladding checked for asbestos before anyone cuts, sands, drills or breaks it. That's not a do-it-yourself job.
A reclad makes sense roughly when repairing starts to cost more than recladding would: repairs now, and more repairs a few years on, against doing it once. But there's a better question: what damage is putting it off doing to the house?
Doing nothing is where the real cost is. If water's getting in behind the cladding, it starts rotting the framing, and the reclad you eventually need becomes a very expensive one. Most of the wall leaks I see were found too late. Caught early, a lot of them are a small repair. Left, they usually spread until the whole house is leaking and you might as well replace it all.
Sometimes the right answer is a repair. If the leak is coming from one isolated fault, repairing it properly can be a lasting fix. Other times, where the cladding is failing more widely and the money isn't there for a reclad, a repair might just buy time. The important thing is knowing which you're paying for.
Bubbling wallpaper or brown marks on a wall? Don't wait to see if they spread. Book a callback and send photos of the marks. Finding where the water's getting in comes first, whatever it turns out to need.
Consent, and who can do the work
Repairs and maintenance with comparable materials don't usually need a building consent: re-screwing a roof, sealing a crack, replacing a few boards. Replacing an old roof like for like often doesn't either, if it's lasted as long as it should have.
Not every cladding repair or replacement needs building consent. If the original cladding has met its 15-year durability requirement, replacing it with comparable materials in the same position may be exempt.
That also means you don't legally need a Licensed Building Practitioner to carry out the work, even though the cladding is an important part of keeping the house weathertight.
Where building consent is required for recladding, the work will generally be restricted building work and must be carried out or supervised by an LBP. If you're not sure where your job sits, ask the council before you start.
What to ask whoever looks at it
You don't need to know how to find a leak to know whether someone has. Ask:
- Have you ruled out the plumbing?
- Where is the water getting in, and what showed you?
- If it's the roof: are there holes in the iron under the ridge caps?
- Will this repair fix the cause of the leak, or is it only intended to buy time? If it's temporary, how long should it last?
- What damage will putting it off do to the house?
- If it's a reclad: does it need a consent, and if so, which Licensed Building Practitioner will be responsible for it?
- If the house is from before 2000 and the job touches fibre-cement cladding: has it been checked for asbestos?
